The long snapper also got a ring... Does that make him more successful?Its a silly game to play if you don't recognize how much more valued a Super Bowl is over a UFC title.
Arthur was never a pro-bowler. Never an all-pro. Was (also) suspended for steroids. Never stayed healthy enough to live up to his contract in Indy and had to restructure before they cut him.
I'm not saying he was bad... Not by any means. But Jon has probably made similar money to him and is probably more well known, even if some of it is due to being a piece of shit.
Chandler... No contest. He's easily the most successful and has managed to keep his nose clean thus far. Jon may be more internationally famous than him but I'll still say that Chandler is more successful.