General Billy Joel v Elton Johm

Welcome to our Community
Wanting to join the rest of our members? Feel free to Sign Up today.
Sign up

Big Dummy

Cream of the Crop
Dec 15, 2018
8,319
12,755
Who hates "Piano Man"? The fuck is wrong with you?

La de dah deh dah....
La la deh dah deh daaaah...
Ugh, I hate that fucking song with a passion and the people that sing along with it. Fuck Davey, who’s still in the Navy.
You can throw Skynyrd’s “Simple Man” in there too.
If I ever hear those 2 songs again, it’ll be too soon.
 

Hauler

Been fallin so long it's like gravitys gone
Feb 3, 2016
45,412
57,814
Ugh, I hate that fucking song with a passion and the people that sing along with it. Fuck Davey, who’s still in the Navy.
You can throw Skynyrd’s “Simple Man” in there too.
If I ever hear those 2 songs again, it’ll be too soon.
I get it.
I have an unjustifiable hatred for GnR's "November Rain"
 

Filthy

Iowa Wrestling Champion
Jun 28, 2016
27,507
29,834
to answer OP:

Billy Joel, and it's not even close.

Elton John's flamboyance was as important to his career as his music.

Billy Joel just had the music.
 

Filthy

Iowa Wrestling Champion
Jun 28, 2016
27,507
29,834
thread needs some Randy Newman, and maybe some Carole King...neither is dead yet AFAIK
 

Big Dummy

Cream of the Crop
Dec 15, 2018
8,319
12,755
That part of the op is as wrong as elton's last name in the title.

You know im right.
Have it your way, Burger King.

As for Elton vs Billy. It’s easy.
I like way more songs from Elton John.
Yellow Brick Rd
Don’t let the Sun go down on me
Funeral for a Friend
I guess that’s why they call it the blues
Candle in the Wind (Princess Di Version)

I don’t care if I ever hear another Billy Joel song for the rest of my life. If he was playing across the street for free, I still wouldn’t go watch him.
 

Qat

QoQ
Nov 3, 2015
16,385
22,624
Have it your way, Burger King.

As for Elton vs Billy. It’s easy.
I like way more songs from Elton John.
Yellow Brick Rd
Don’t let the Sun go down on me
Funeral for a Friend
I guess that’s why they call it the blues
Candle in the Wind (Princess Di Version)

I don’t care if I ever hear another Billy Joel song for the rest of my life. If he was playing across the street for free, I still wouldn’t go watch him.
Well you are just an ass without ears, but in this case your answer is correct.

Must be luck.
 

NotBanjaxo

Formerly someone other than Banjaxo
Nov 16, 2019
8,305
17,709
I get it.
I have an unjustifiable hatred for GnR's "November Rain"
Oh, that was fucking awful. Worst song they ever did.

My all time "hated song that everyone seems to like" is Wonderwall by Oasis. It's three minutes of Liam whining like a bitch, like fingernails on a chalkboard.
 

JimmyHonda

Lurker
Jun 27, 2022
4
4
both are corny as fuck but gotta go with elton. piano man is one of the worst songs of all time. "sharing a drink we call loneliness" ugh