Society 900 suspected pedophiles arrested as ‘darknet’ child porn kingpin jailed for 30yrs

Welcome to our Community
Wanting to join the rest of our members? Feel free to Sign Up today.
Sign up

Zeph

TMMAC Addict
Jan 22, 2015
24,355
32,126
Nearly 900 members of a global ‘dark web’ pedophile ring sprawling Europe and the Americas have been arrested following a two-year investigation, the FBI and Europol reported after the website’s founder was handed a 30-year jail sentence.
Shedding light on the scope of the operation which is still active, the FBI revealed that in the US alone, 350 arrests were made as part of a wide-ranging investigation into Playpen – a secret website that is being referred to as possibly the biggest child pornography online dump that ever existed.

Read more
FBI ran 23 Dark Web child porn sites to gather visitor info
The arrests and other law enforcement actions related to the investigation were carried out “in countries far and near”, including Turkey, Peru, Chile, Ukraine, Israel and Malaysia, according to the FBI.

Europe accounts for the major share of arrests and convictions with 368 suspects being charged. A total of 870 arrests were made in connection with the case, according to Europol.

Over 300 children who had suffered sexual abuse at the hands of Playpen members have been identified or rescued.

EU Commissioner for the Security Union, Sir Julian King, said “a hugely significant blow has been struck against one of the most heinous of crimes, arguably the worst of all, thanks to the excellent transnational cooperation of Europol with the FBI and US Department of Justice, as well as other law enforcement agencies around the world.”

Playpen’s founder, Steven W. Chase, 58, was sentenced Monday to 30 years behind bars. The site he set up in August 2014 boasted some 150,000 users worldwide until it was taken down by the FBI following a controversial covert operation.


The agency said it had uncovered the site almost immediately after it had been launched but lacked information to trace the location or identity of the site’s owner as it was rooted in the deep web, meaning the site was only accessible through special software such as Tor.

Tor grants anonymity to its users and thereby is often described as a convenient platform for illicit activities, such as selling weapons, drugs or disseminating pornography.

However, Florida-based Chase inadvertently slipped up, revealing his site’s IP address, providing law enforcement with all the necessary leads.

Two of Chase’s aides, Michael Fluckiger and David Browning, both US citizens – who served as administrators of the site – were each jailed for 20 years.

Read more
US govt allows child porn suspect off hook in bid to protect Tor hack method
Through a subsequent operation codenamed Operation Pacifier, the FBI succeeded in tracking down hundreds of the site’s users, sending “more than 1,000 leads” to FBI agents as well as to European authorities.

The FBI has been criticized for what it called a “court-approved network investigative technique” used to unearth information about the suspects. It emerged that the agency, with court approval, seized and ran the pedophile website for 13 days in February 2015.

The FBI’s command of the Playpen site enabled the agency to infect over 8,000 users’ computers with malware and hack them. Notably, the site was said to be more efficient and even experienced a boost in audience numbers with the FBI in charge of its content.

Internet privacy experts found the FBI’s handling of the case highly questionable and contrary to privacy laws.

“The warrant here did not identify any particular person to search or seize. Nor did it identify any specific user of the targeted website,” Electronic Frontier Foundation said, calling into question the legality of the FBI’s actions.

However, the head of the European Cybercrime Centre (EC3), Steven Wilson, appeared to defend the controversial practice, saying in a statement that “If we operate with 19th century legal principles then we are unable to effectively tackle crime at the highest level.”

“We need to balance the rights of victims versus the right to privacy,” Wilson argued, praising the cooperation between the US and European law enforcement in the case.

900 suspected pedophiles arrested as ‘darknet’ child porn kingpin jailed for 30yrs
 

b00ts

pews&vrooms
Amateur Fighter
Oct 21, 2015
5,599
8,635
So the FBI ran a pedophile site for 2 weeks? Hypocrites.
 

b00ts

pews&vrooms
Amateur Fighter
Oct 21, 2015
5,599
8,635
so you'd rather they just shut it down and not catch 900 pedos?
Getting access to users is one thing. Putting up content is another. From the way I'm reading it, the FBI was hands on with posting child porn as well. There's got to be a different way to go about that.
 

Robbie Hart

All Biden Voters Are Mindless Sheep
Feb 13, 2015
49,774
50,754
This is where I have no problem with those gumshoes invading people's privacy.......
 

Zeph

TMMAC Addict
Jan 22, 2015
24,355
32,126
Getting access to users is one thing. Putting up content is another. From the way I'm reading it, the FBI was hands on with posting child porn as well. There's got to be a different way to go about that.
Without knowing the details I can make a decent guess on why this might have been done. It has to do with how the Tor network works. Tor has a certain number of distributed nodes across the world, and when you connect to Tor you connect to any one of these random nodes with your information being sent randomly across the nodes to reach the destination website, and your information is sent back again randomly. It's through this means that it provides a high degree on anonymity, unlike normal internet, and is why it's used for many illicit means.

However, there was talk a few years back of the FBI compromising a number of those nodes, which would allow them to monitor traffic across the network, assuming they have compromised enough. I haven't kept up on the situation, but I would imagine it's sort of like a race between nodes being compromised, new ones popping up, and compromised nodes being removed from the network.

Now assuming they can monitor who is accessing the site, as sites like these doubtless don't keep logs normally, with enough of the compromised nodes they can analyse where the connection are coming from and catch the users of the site. Which is, likely, why they ran the site for a few weeks to gain the enough data to narrow down the vast majority of the users. Without keeping up appearances regular users would notice and go dark, leaving them free from being caught.

It's not a nice thought, or job, but sometimes these sorts of things need to be done to save more people, in this case children, in the future.
 

Splinty

Shake 'em off
Admin
Dec 31, 2014
44,116
91,096
Which is, likely, why they ran the site for a few weeks to gain the enough data to narrow down the vast majority of the users.
Majority?
They got 1500 IPs... Out of 150,000+

And the cases are getting tossed because no one can trust the IP data because the FBI won't release the JavaScript

FBI won't reveal hack, so child porn evidence tossed

Speaking of JavaScript, I'd guess the typical pedo creating content knows not to run scripts via tor, which you have to explicitly do. But I bet new people and low level people don't know that. So I'd guess there's a selection of people that don't really matter caught here. The FBI regularly has used ads on legal porn sites and chan boards to ADVERTISE sting operations of this nature in the past. Who would know a girl is under 18 if marketed from a legal website?? And do I really want to prioritize people being marketed towards this, instead of the actually active members and content creators? I'd suggest all signs point to these IPs being the reverse of that goal, the most dangerous and exploiting. Except the sure owners...who they already had.

In the meantime, new content was created and distributed in ever efficient means as THE FBI UPGRADED THE PEDO SERVER.

The FBI didn't have a legal exception to distribute child porn and the judge that gave a warrant has been a multi-year debate about his actual understanding of the warrant he authorized (he doesn't seem to understand, but also seemed he would have granted anyways).

Might as well go fuck some prostitutes before you arrest them.
 

Splinty

Shake 'em off
Admin
Dec 31, 2014
44,116
91,096
Only partly rhetorical...

How many children getting abused were spread on the dark web for the first time in that two weeks? Enabling that abuse is worth catching how many pedo site users?


At some point, the FBI assisted in children being fucked and exploited for money and sexual gratification....for the greater good.
 

Gay For Longo

*insert Matt Serra meme
Jan 22, 2016
16,758
18,014
So the FBI ran a pedophile site for 2 weeks? Hypocrites.
This happens on the darkweb more than you can imagine
Edit: by this I mean that there are A LOT of honeypots on there

I'm glad they caught the Fuck, just hope they actually follow through on the charges
If he's the kingpin, I guess they may use this to justify dropping other charges on others
 
Last edited:

Filthy

Iowa Wrestling Champion
Jun 28, 2016
27,507
29,834
the problem is that the FBI and the Justice Dept use cases like this to establish precedent when what they want to do is, on it's surface, unconstitutional. Of course they're going to spin hard the number or perps they caught, but I'd rather that a thousand pedo watchers go free than give up my 4th Amendment rights, or set the precedent that the Justice System is permitted to do much Evil if they're plan (because the result was not guaranteed) is to do some theoretically larger Good.

Government is the name we give to the things that we all do together, and the first rule of representative government is "Do No Evil"
 

Splinty

Shake 'em off
Admin
Dec 31, 2014
44,116
91,096
Majority?
They got 1500 IPs... Out of 150,000+

And the cases are getting tossed because no one can trust the IP data because the FBI won't release the JavaScript

FBI won't reveal hack, so child porn evidence tossed

Speaking of JavaScript, I'd guess the typical pedo creating content knows not to run scripts via tor, which you have to explicitly do. But I bet new people and low level people don't know that. So I'd guess there's a selection of people that don't really matter caught here. The FBI regularly has used ads on legal porn sites and chan boards to ADVERTISE sting operations of this nature in the past. Who would know a girl is under 18 if marketed from a legal website?? And do I really want to prioritize people being marketed towards this, instead of the actually active members and content creators? I'd suggest all signs point to these IPs being the reverse of that goal, the most dangerous and exploiting. Except the sure owners...who they already had.

In the meantime, new content was created and distributed in ever efficient means as THE FBI UPGRADED THE PEDO SERVER.

The FBI didn't have a legal exception to distribute child porn and the judge that gave a warrant has been a multi-year debate about his actual understanding of the warrant he authorized (he doesn't seem to understand, but also seemed he would have granted anyways).

Might as well go fuck some prostitutes before you arrest them.

dirty pedo is dead to rights but the FBI screwed it all up by cutting corners...
Charges dismissed against former Vancouver teacher in child porn case

But FBI appeals and gets a win for the general strategy, even though THE WARRANT WAS ILLEGAL per the court:
Good Faith Beats Bad Warrant In Another Win For FBI's World-Traversing NIT Malware

and again courts agree
Sixth Circuit Appeals Court Latest To Say It's Cool If The FBI Broke The Law During Its Playpen Investigation

But the foundation of this seems to be the grey area the FBI operated in and now that is clarified so must warrants. So this might apply to the previous case, but no more. But it does say that if its a grey area, law enforcement should move forward "in good faith" because that's the basic precedent that's set. Good to get the pedos, but yikes at that ruling.
 

sparkuri

Pulse On The Finger Of The Community
First 100
Jan 16, 2015
34,609
46,694
What a joke, sick one at that.
LE should be charged with negligence AT LEAST, and defunded.
Leave it to the pro's, whatever agency that is, apparently.