GOAT (Poll)
- Thread starter Wild
- Start date
All 4 have their great time periods
Jones has had a couple of decisions thrown his way and steroid usage so I’m gonna have to drop him from contention
Fedor fought too long but had a great run in pride that can’t be touched, ever and that is the greatest run by a heavyweight, ever
Grid Supply Point had a great run but he did take some losses that were preventable so I can’t fully back him in these talks
Khabib impressed the shit out of me tonight and is undefeated, he’s the greatest of all time.
Jones has had a couple of decisions thrown his way and steroid usage so I’m gonna have to drop him from contention
Fedor fought too long but had a great run in pride that can’t be touched, ever and that is the greatest run by a heavyweight, ever
Grid Supply Point had a great run but he did take some losses that were preventable so I can’t fully back him in these talks
Khabib impressed the shit out of me tonight and is undefeated, he’s the greatest of all time.
GSP is the best ever. He went through murderers row during his run. Then left to bang whores for a few years and came back to win the strap in another division. Khabib is a monster and clearly the best in recent years, but he has a lot of wins over guys that were so so
the list should also include Anderson Silva, but i guess since he has a positive test he can be excluded. If that’s the case, please remove Jones as well.
the list should also include Anderson Silva, but i guess since he has a positive test he can be excluded. If that’s the case, please remove Jones as well.
Last edited:
And even this far past his prime there are still people that think GSP is the only guy to have a chance at Khabib.
I've been a GSP homer since the day he started, but Khabib is 29-0 and hasn't lost a round (don't care how Sal scored the first round he's a hack)
Khabib has never been roughed, beaten and bruised post fight.
It's close, but I give Khabib the slight edge over GSP.
Khabib has never been roughed, beaten and bruised post fight.
It's close, but I give Khabib the slight edge over GSP.
Another question. Will Khabib return for a GSP fight? It was his father's wish to see them square up.
I say that's the only fight that would bring him back.
I say that's the only fight that would bring him back.
But is he a once in a lifetime athlete? Will Rogan get all emotional and start sobbing over his accomplishments?
Last edited:
M
member 3289
Guest
One thing to keep in mind is age. Everyone will lose if they fought long enough.
*Fedor's age at first lose- 33 yrs.
*Khabib first lose? Retired at 32.
*GSP retired at 32 besides one comeback fight.
*Jones has too many questions to be considered IMO.
*Fedor's age at first lose- 33 yrs.
*Khabib first lose? Retired at 32.
*GSP retired at 32 besides one comeback fight.
*Jones has too many questions to be considered IMO.
M
member 3289
Guest
Ahh! You're one of those 'official scorecards are official' lads.
All of those judges are bought and paid for. Especially Sal.
Seriously though, khabibs record is ridiculous. Mind you, GSP went on a tear of his own, with over 30 rounds without losing on the scorecards
Exclusions of such greats like David Terell and Sean Salmon in the OP is somewhat disheartening.