They weren't really wasted talent, in my opinion anyways.
Every single time they'd win the belts or get any amount of momentum, Rey Phoenix would break an arm or something else. Or when they were a trios team with Pac, but Pac would either be injured or just not want to travel so he'd be off TV for months at a time. They were given plenty of opportunities but couldn't stay available.
Penta's singles run on the other hand left more to be desired. He was easily one of the more over guys in the company at one point and he'd just lose clean to anybody and everybody. Never made any sense to me.
Loved them in AEW, but it did feel they deserved better. One of the matches that really got me into AEW was them vs the Young Bucks a couple of years ago. I saw it and thought this is so much better than anything that WWE was putting out. Hope they succeed in the big show.
There is not a single tag team in all of WWE that's anywhere close to the Lucha Bros. They should come in, unify the belts, and run roughshot on absolutely everyone.
Also - for the love of all that's holy, puhhhlleeeaaaaaassssseeeeee Triple H, give us Lucha Underground era Pentagon Dark.
lol...so over just a couple days it goes from "They already signed a multi-year deal, and WWE is already making their merch" to "no they aren't signed."
Whomever "broke" that story has some 'splainin' to dooooo...