@conor mcgregor nut hugger we used
this recipe with some changes below.
Ingredients:
2 Cups sourdough starter (What I like to do is a few days before, take the culture out of the fridge, take what you would normally discard and put it into another bowl and then feed both. You will keep your original starter plus this one you will use for the recipe. 2 cups is a lot of starter and we almost depleted it all the way the first time we made the bagels)
1 1/4- 1 1/2 cup warm water (when mixing the dough you may need to add a tad bit more to the 1 1/4 cups)
1 tablespoon oil (we have been use canola oil)
5 Cups of Bread Flour (Obviously King Arthur brand, all other flour is inferior, just ask
@Splinty)
1 tablespoon salt
1 Tablespoon baking soda (I just eyeball it, my wife measures it)
For toppings
We use an everything bagel blend we got off Amazon
And heavy cream (We brush this onto the bagels after they are boiled, before we put to toppings on)
Instructions
1. In the order listed mix the following ingredients. What we do is add the starter, add the water, mix together. Add the oil, mix together etc
Starter
1 1/4 Cup Warm Water
Oil
Flour (we add a cup at a time, get it mixed, add another cup etc)
salt
2. Let the dough rest for 10-15 min, this will make it more homogeneous. It will look like a shaggy mess before you do this. You will add the last 1/4 cup of warm water here if it is incredibly hard to work with, you may not feel you need it and that's fine.
3. Kneed the dough for 4-6 min using a stand mixer and dough hook, or about 15 min by hand. The dough is going to be very stiff, this is expected.
4. Put the dough into a large, greased bowl and cover with a damp towel for 4 hours. During this time you will fold the dough into it self twice and flip the dough over so the folds are now on the bottom. Folding dough video:
View: https://youtu.be/hO8Kt0r00lo?t=34
5. Pour out the dough onto a floured surface or a tea towel with flour on it (this is what we do). Knead the dough a view times, flatten and try to work out the fold lines, cut into short fat chunks weighing 4-5 oz. You should get 12-14. Scrunch the dough together and then in the side where the cut was made, push your thumb through to make a hole, work the dough around your thumb expanding it until you can fit your pointing and middle finger in and work the dough into a circle. Place the formed bagels onto your backing sheet 6-8 will fit depending on sheet size and bagel size. We line our baking sheets with parchment paper. Once done cover with a damp towel, and let rise for 60-90 minutes.
6. After the 60-90 minutes has passed fill a large, deep skillet with water and add the baking soda. Turn on your oven to 415 at this time so it can preheat. After you've made the bagels you may adjust the temp to what works best for you. Once the water is boiling frop in 2-3 bagels at a time, boil for 60 seconds, flipping at the 30 second mark. Take the bagels out and put them on their baking sheets. While fresh out of the water brush heavy cream or milk onto the bagels, add your seasoning. Once 2 baking sheets worth of bagels have been boiled place them into the oven for 14-16 minutes. You may want to switch the positions of the trays half way though.
7. Let bagels cool on a rack.
8. You probably wont eat all the bagels in a day so for the bagels you wont eat that day slice the bagels 85% of the way through, bag, and put in a freezer. We vacuum seal ours in 2 packs, when vacuum sealing seal the bag before the bagel compresses down.
Boom, you now have great bagels. If you want your bagels more well done you could run at 425-450 for 14-15 min, we like ours to be soft and fluffy, we feel they taste better that way. But that's the nice thing about making your own, you can get them exactly how you like them. We individually vacuum seal ours and freeze them. The thaw quickly and they don't go stale. When you vacuum seal them you don't need to get all the air out and you don't want to because it will squish them down. I let some air get sucked out and then press the seal button before it compresses them.