Tories caught spending public money to hide ex-health secretary Andrew Lansley’s secrets

Welcome to our Community
Wanting to join the rest of our members? Feel free to Sign Up today.
Sign up

Zeph

TMMAC Addict
Jan 22, 2015
24,348
31,961
Conservative ministers have paid thousands to try and prevent the public from knowing which lobbyists and private health care companies Andrew Lansley met when he was health secretary preparing to privatise the National Health Service.

Lansley constructed The Health & Social Care Act 2012 which became law in April 2013. It has had major consequences for the NHS and meant that:

  • The health secretary was no longer responsible for the NHS.
  • The strategic centres of the NHS, such as Strategic Health Authorities and Primary Healthcare Trusts, would be dismantled. This effectively denationalised the service, removing the economies of scale and guarantees of standardised service regardless of where you live in the country.
  • This paved the way to ensure that up to 49% of beds in any NHS hospital can be handed over to private providers.
Although Lansley was replaced by Jeremy Hunt in September 2012, health experts have described the former Health Secretary’s changes as “damaging and distracting,” and fundamental to the problems that the NHS faces today.

Since he resigned as Health Secretary and quit being an MP, Lansley has been made a peer. He has also been providing Bain and Company, a management consultancy firm, with his expertise on how to advise healthcare firms who have reaped the rewards of his reforms. They commended his reforms and said to previous clients:

what was traditionally locked up in the NHS is going to become available to the private sector.

He has also earned money advising drug company Roche, who have been in a row with the NHS over their expensive pharmaceutical products. Roche has benefited massively from the cancer drugs fund that Lansley constructed and they paid him in November to provide them advice on “supply and pricing issues in Europe”. Around the same time, Lansley has also been providing support to Blackstone, a private healthcare firm. His role is to provide advice on investment opportunities in the field that he helped to carve up.

But what Conservative ministers have tried to keep under wraps is the meetings he has held with these type of firms when he was Health Secretary. A freedom of information (FoI) request was submitted to reveal the nature of these meetings, which has embarrassed the government no end. The government has spent around £30,000 on legal funds to try and keep Lansley’s diary a secret. This is more than enough to pay a nurse’s wage for a year.

Unsurprisingly, many campaigners are disgusted with the fact that Lansley can benefit from the very reforms he enacted and are seeking to discover which firms he had met with. Maurice Frankel, the head of the Campaign for Freedom of Information said to a parliamentary commission:

We’ve seen a series of appeals on a decision regarding Andrew Lansley’s diaries.

We’ve asked for the costs of the government’s legal advice, which they’ve refused to disclose.

I estimate the costs are probably close to £30,000 – and still going up.

After a ruling in April said that the public should be able to see ministerial diaries, the government has been fighting tooth and nail to prevent FoI requests and has taken this to the Court of Appeal. The government is desperate to water down the act because they allege it is too costly to implement. Frankel argued that the government’s position was ironic considering the lengths and expense they go to to hide their murky secrets:

Talk about the ‘burden of FoI’ – some of the burden is caused by authorities trying to resist disclosure beyond the point at which they should simply accept the decision.

This raises serious questions about the interests of our government and politicians.

Firstly, Lansley’s strong links to corporations that have benefited directly from his reforms emphasise the revolving door between politics and business. Only last week the former Labour chancellor Alistair Darling became a director at banking firm Morgan Stanely, the same week as Gordon Brown, the former prime minister, became an adviser to the largest bond manager, Pimco.

It also poses serious questions about why the government is willing to spend large sums of money to hide information from the public. Politicians are using their positions of power to act in their own interests, and the government is protecting them from scrutiny in the most undemocratic way possible.

Tories caught spending public money to hide ex-health secretary Andrew Lansley's secrets | The Canary
 
M

member 3289

Guest
Explain the NHS to me (briefly). Is it public institutions or private institutions?
 

Leigh

Engineer
Pro Fighter
Jan 26, 2015
10,912
21,059
Explain the NHS to me (briefly). Is it public institutions or private institutions?
Free health care service. In the UK, you don't have to have medical insurance to visit a doctor or get hospital treatment. It is funded by the NHS which in turn is funded by tax payers. It is riddled with abuse and on it's last legs. If the Conservatives shut it down, they are unlikely to win any election for quite a while.
 

ThatOneDude

Commander in @Chief, Dick Army
First 100
Jan 14, 2015
35,368
34,139
Free health care service. In the UK, you don't have to have medical insurance to visit a doctor or get hospital treatment. It is funded by the NHS which in turn is funded by tax payers. It is riddled with abuse and on it's last legs. If the Conservatives shut it down, they are unlikely to win any election for quite a while.
So if it's on its last leg and the conservatives shut it down, what's the issue.

Mind you I know NOTHING about politics in the UK
 

HEATH VON DOOM

Remember the 5th of November
Oct 21, 2015
17,274
24,682
So which side are the torries, and if its so awfull why would shutting it down be so bad? Will it not be replaced? I know one Brit personally and he told me your public healthcare was a joke years ago, and almost all decent jobs still had to offer private care to get the best employees.

nick diaz is my nut hugger
 

Zeph

TMMAC Addict
Jan 22, 2015
24,348
31,961
So if it's on its last leg and the conservatives shut it down, what's the issue.

Mind you I know NOTHING about politics in the UK
It's not on it's last legs. it's a large robust service, that like any large program suffers from some waste and mismanagement.
 

Leigh

Engineer
Pro Fighter
Jan 26, 2015
10,912
21,059
So if it's on its last leg and the conservatives shut it down, what's the issue.

Mind you I know NOTHING about politics in the UK
Because it absolutely can be saved. It will take some drastic changes though.
 
M

member 3289

Guest
Free health care service. In the UK, you don't have to have medical insurance to visit a doctor or get hospital treatment. It is funded by the NHS which in turn is funded by tax payers. It is riddled with abuse and on it's last legs. If the Conservatives shut it down, they are unlikely to win any election for quite a while.
So you go to the doctor and get treated, and then how does the doctor get paid?
 

Zeph

TMMAC Addict
Jan 22, 2015
24,348
31,961
I see. Is it decent money, or could they make better money in other European countries?
They would make more money as a banker, but it isn't bad money. I can't say what they would make in other countries. The job is also a highly respected profession, which plays into it's attractiveness, women dig a doctor.
 

HEATH VON DOOM

Remember the 5th of November
Oct 21, 2015
17,274
24,682
They would make more money as a banker, but it isn't bad money. I can't say what they would make in other countries. The job is also a highly respected profession, which plays into it's attractiveness, women dig a doctor.
Do the doctors have a choice to be a NHS doctor or private doctor?

nick diaz is my nut hugger
 

Leigh

Engineer
Pro Fighter
Jan 26, 2015
10,912
21,059
Like wiping it out and starting fresh? Or are they saying just be done with it.
Not starting fresh but a big overhaul. A lot of people abuse the service and take it for granted. There is a LOT of corruption, like the story in the OP. And as Zeph @Zeph says, there is mismanagement (I probably consider it worse than he does).

I see. Is it decent money, or could they make better money in other European countries?
Doctors do OK but would make a lot more abroad and many move to Australia, where their salaries are doubled. Nurses suffer quite badly. They need to be university educated but are given long, crappy hours and pay freezes or even cuts.
 

Leigh

Engineer
Pro Fighter
Jan 26, 2015
10,912
21,059
Do the doctors have a choice to be a NHS doctor or private doctor?

nick diaz is my nut hugger
Yes but the ratio is not close to being even. Private health care is pretty much a luxury here (I have it ;) )
 

Zeph

TMMAC Addict
Jan 22, 2015
24,348
31,961
Not starting fresh but a big overhaul. A lot of people abuse the service and take it for granted. There is a LOT of corruption, like the story in the OP. And as Zeph @Zeph says, there is mismanagement (I probably consider it worse than he does).


Doctors do OK but would make a lot more abroad and many move to Australia, where their salaries are doubled. Nurses suffer quite badly. They need to be university educated but are given long, crappy hours and pay freezes or even cuts.
They also get that university education for free, but they are some of the hardest working people I've met. I had 3 nurses for housemates at uni and they worked really hard. Nurses deserve a lot of respect.
 

HEATH VON DOOM

Remember the 5th of November
Oct 21, 2015
17,274
24,682
Are there long waits for surgeries deemed minor? In the states you can pretty much get a blown out knee fixed within weeks if you want. I am intrigued by your system if the human element could be taken out of it, but we are Americans and we don't like to wait for shit either.

nick diaz is my nut hugger
 

Leigh

Engineer
Pro Fighter
Jan 26, 2015
10,912
21,059
Are there long waits for surgeries deemed minor? In the states you can pretty much get a blown out knee fixed within weeks if you want. I am intrigued by your system if the human element could be taken out of it, but we are Americans and we don't like to wait for shit either.

nick diaz is my nut hugger
Yes there are long waits and they are not popular.
 

HEATH VON DOOM

Remember the 5th of November
Oct 21, 2015
17,274
24,682
Yes there are long waits and they are not popular.
So if you have bronchitis, something pretty simple to treat but requires prescrition meds, is it easy to get treatment for that or is there also a wait?

nick diaz is my nut hugger
 

Leigh

Engineer
Pro Fighter
Jan 26, 2015
10,912
21,059
So if you have bronchitis, something pretty simple to treat but requires prescrition meds, is it easy to get treatment for that or is there also a wait?

nick diaz is my nut hugger
Prescriptions are easy. Getting an appointment to see a doctor to get the prescription is usually same day.