Dave's Song of the Day
Down By the Water – PJ Harvey
Saturday song of the day: No, the singer of today’s song didn’t really drown her daughter.
Polly Jean Harvey’s 1995 hit
Down by the Water tells the story of a woman who drowned her daughter and now is feeling regret. It was her breakthrough hit in the United States, but the odd theme caused some peculiar theories that Harvey had actually done something similar.
Some people take songs way too literally. Mick Jagger was not born in a crossfire hurricane, John Lennon is not a walrus, and as far as I know, Johnny Cash did not shoot a man in Reno just to watch him die. But apparently a few people thought
Down by the Water was autobiographical. According to PJ Harvey, “Some critics have taken my writing so literally to the point that they’ll listen to
Down by the Water and believe I have actually given birth to a child and drowned her.”
As mentioned,
Down by the Water was PJ Harvey’s breakthrough hit in the US. She had received critical acclaim with her debut album
Dry in 1992.
Down by the Water was on her third album,
To Bring You My Love, and the musical direction included more electronic instrumentation than her earlier work. The song was released as a single in February 1995 and rose to #2 on the
Billboard Modern Rock chart, and #48 on the
Billboard Hot 100. I happened to see PJ Harvey in concert in September 1995 with Veruca Salt and Live at the Merriweather Post Pavilion in Maryland. Harvey put on a good show, and
Down by the Water was one of the highlights.
Tomorrow: You may see a stranger