Dave's Song of the Day
Manish Boy – Muddy Waters and His Guitar
Wednesday song of the day: Todays song is both a re-write and an answer to yesterday’s song.
As mentioned yesterday, Bo Diddley was inspired by the Muddy Waters songs
Hoochie Coochie Man and
She Moves Me when writing his 1955 hit
I’m a Man. Waters immediately took note of Diddley’s homage and that same year recorded his own version of
I’m a Man, with some of the lyrics rewritten to reflect the differences in age and experience between the two musicians. At the time of the recording in May 1955, Muddy Waters was 42 years old and had been in the music business since the 1930s, while Bo Diddley was a relatively young 26 years old and had just begun his recording career. (By the way, today would have been Bo Diddley’s 92nd birthday.) To playfully one-up the younger man, Waters referred to the age difference in the song, which he titled
Manish Boy. (Later versions corrected the spelling to
Mannish Boy.)
The implication was that Diddley was merely a boy in comparison – a “mannish boy” to be sure – but not yet the “full grown man” that Muddy declared himself to be. For example, note how this portion of the original lyrics in
I’m a Man compares to the rewritten lyrics sung by the older Waters in
Manish Boy:
Bo Diddley’s lyric,
Now I’m a man,
Made twenty-one,
You know baby,
We can have a lot of fun.
became in later Waters recordings,
But now I’m a man,
Way past twenty-one,
Want you to believe me baby,
I had lots of fun.
The new lyrics changed Bo’s statement that he had arrived as a young man to Waters’ declaration that he had been there and done that, while the younger man still had some things to learn. As a reworking of the original song, the writing credits for
Manish Boy included Bo Diddley (under his real name of Ellas McDaniels) as well as Muddy Waters (under his real name of McKinley Morganfield) and Waters’ co-writer Mel London.
Manish Boy was released as a single in June 1955, just two months after Bo Diddley had released
I’m a Man. It was a hit, peaking at #5 on the R&B chart just a few weeks after the original song that it answered had made #1 on the same chart. In 1986,
Manish Boy was inducted into the Blues Hall of Fame, where it would be joined in 2018 by the induction of Diddley’s
I’m a Man.
Like the song it was based upon,
Manish Boy – or more properly,
Mannish Boy – has been covered by numerous artists over the years. Jimi Hendrix recorded a version with the Band of Gypsys before his death in 1970, but the track was unreleased until 1994. The Rolling Stones (whose very name came from the 1950 Muddy Waters song
Rollin’ Stone) often performed
Mannish Boy in concert, including it on their 1977 album
Love You Live. A few years later, the Stones performed it with Muddy Waters himself for the concert video and live album
Live at the Checkerboard Lounge, Chicago 1981.
View: https://youtu.be/i-R9qiS_n50
Jimmy Hendrix (with the Band of Gypsys), 1970
View: https://youtu.be/0t0Qp9K_y6M
Muddy Waters with The Rolling Stones, 1981
View: https://youtu.be/sc_GVeeo-20
Tomorrow: Kings and queens step aside