Where does Payton Manning rank all time?

[BeardOfKnowledge]

I wouldnt put him on Montana level but i would put him ahead of his brother just for the fact he made it to more.

They won the same amount and Peyton never rose to the occasion like this:

 

[BeardOfKnowledge]

Just to play Devils advocate, do you have solid proof of this?

Enough to get a conviction? No. Enough to get a hypothetical warrant and put him on trial? Fuck, yes.

Unexpected comeback from injury? check.
"Late career resurgence"? check.
Professional affiliation with a steroid provider? check.
Admissions by a known steroid provider? check

I obviously have no rock hard evidence, but the writing is pretty clearly on the wall.

 

[Hauler]

I won't list them in numerical order as arguments can be made for either guy to move in either direction, but in no particular order my QB Top 5 is.......Brady, Favre, Marino, Manning & Montana.

 

[Hauler]

They won the same amount and Peyton never rose to the occasion like this:

Dude. That's not exactly Eli rising to the occasion. That was put up for grabs. One hell of a catch, but 99 times out of 100 that's either incomplete or intercepted.

 

[BeardOfKnowledge]

Dude. That's not exactly Eli rising to the occasion. That was put up for grabs. One hell of a catch, but 99 times out of 100 that's either incomplete or intercepted.

The presence of mind to break several tackles and be able to make a reasonable throw is what's impressive about that sequence.

 

[Tiiimmmaaayyy]

Here's my Top 5

1. Joe Montana
2. Troy Aikman
3. Terry Bradshaw
4. Steve Young
5. Tom Brady

I have Payton at 6

would happily debate the top 5 guys. An argument could be made for most of the guys you listed. One thing that can't be argued is FUCK TOM BRADY!!!

Peyton and Marino are top 5. Montana also must be included. I don't know enough to about Unitas to say for sure. I'm pretty sure Uncle Rico would've made the list if coach would have just put him in the 4th quarter.

 

[Treadstone06]

Playing a real sport? Somewhere under 10 blue.

 

[Sweets]

Ye that was a bad one, barely legal assassination job. They played on while medics checked him out on the pitch but he was good to play. I posted it cause that dude is doing the same job as a QB.