Where does Payton Manning rank all time?

Welcome to our Community
Wanting to join the rest of our members? Feel free to Sign Up today.
Sign up

Papi Chingon

Domesticated Hombre
Oct 19, 2015
27,828
34,772
Yes, he is top 5 all time.

Here is a feel good story:
John Elway sat down with Peyton prior to this season and said he wanted to restructure his contract from $19m to $12m. Peyton countered the offer and then they settled on $15m. Peyton wanted incentives included to make back the $4m lost, so he had a clause that gave him a $2m bonus if denver won the AFC title, then an additional $2m if they won the super bowl.
 

Jesus X

4 drink minimum.
Sep 7, 2015
29,688
32,095
Yes, he is top 5 all time.

Here is a feel good story:
John Elway sat down with Peyton prior to this season and said he wanted to restructure his contract from $19m to $12m. Peyton countered the offer and then they settled on $15m. Peyton wanted incentives included to make back the $4m lost, so he had a clause that gave him a $2m bonus if denver won the AFC title, then an additional $2m if they won the super bowl.
Peyton aka killa P has those papa johns business skills
 

teamquestnorth

Lindland never cheated
Jan 27, 2015
15,422
28,226
Here's my Top 5

1. Joe Montana
2. Troy Aikman
3. Terry Bradshaw
4. Steve Young
5. Tom Brady

I have Payton at 6
 

maurice

Posting Machine
Oct 21, 2015
1,359
2,298
He should give the $4m bonus to the Denver defense. Hell, he should give them the salary portion too.
 

Robbie Hart

All Kamala Voters Are Born Losers, Ha Ha Ha
Feb 13, 2015
51,652
51,955
Troy Aikman
Roger Staubach
Danny White
Steve Pelleur
Rodney Peete

These are legends
 

BeardOfKnowledge

The Most Consistent Motherfucker You Know
Jul 22, 2015
60,892
56,359
Top 5 regular season, Top 10 All Time.

If I want to make the playoffs, there isn't many better. If it's the 4th quarter in a Super Bowl, I don't want him anywhere near the field. If I'm being honest I'd rather Eli than Peyton.

Peyton was also using, so there's that.
 

ShatsBassoon

Throwing bombs & banging moms
First 100
Jan 14, 2015
18,605
33,617
Yes, he is top 5 all time.

Here is a feel good story:
John Elway sat down with Peyton prior to this season and said he wanted to restructure his contract from $19m to $12m. Peyton countered the offer and then they settled on $15m. Peyton wanted incentives included to make back the $4m lost, so he had a clause that gave him a $2m bonus if denver won the AFC title, then an additional $2m if they won the super bowl.
Also the million he got everytime he dropped "drink busweiser" in the post game interviews.
 

ECC170

Monster's 11,ATM 2,Parlay Challenge,Hero GP Champ
Pro Fighter
Jan 23, 2015
14,546
23,862
Top 3
200 wins(record)
most TD ina season (record)
5x mvp (record)
most wins in a decade (record)
71,000 passing yards (record)
539 TD (record)
only qb to win a ring with two teams

Ppl can say what they want bit he played on teams that never had a D..I'm glad he finally got a good D....He's by far the most prolific passer we have ever seen
 

HEATH VON DOOM

Remember the 5th of November
Oct 21, 2015
17,277
24,677
People look at his 2-3 record in superbowls and judge him on that and how bad he was this year.
 

BeardOfKnowledge

The Most Consistent Motherfucker You Know
Jul 22, 2015
60,892
56,359
People look at his 2-3 record in superbowls and judge him on that
Ultimately how you perform on the grandest stage is very relevant. Most of the other guys in the GOAT conversation rose to the occasion. To me that's where Peyton eliminates himself from the conversation. For what it's worth he's 2-2 in Super Bowls.
 

HEATH VON DOOM

Remember the 5th of November
Oct 21, 2015
17,277
24,677
Ultimately how you perform on the grandest stage is very relevant. Most of the other guys in the GOAT conversation rose to the occasion. To me that's where Peyton eliminates himself from the conversation. For what it's worth he's 2-2 in Super Bowls.
I wouldnt put him on Montana level but i would put him ahead of his brother just for the fact he made it to more.