Sometimes better. Sometimes worse. The narrators choice of volume, pacing, and emotion can impact how a listener intetprets the plot vs how he or she would have if he or she had read it.Listening too doesn't equal reading.
But the narrator for this one was pretty good. I think my lack of enjoyment stemmed from the plot revolving around a twist, and having already seen the movie, I knew the twist
I read Tom perlotta's (sp?) "The leftovers" and believe that I may not have enjoyed that book for the same reason (I had already seen seasons 1 and 2 of the show on HBO)