Welp, it's over!
I'll write up a rant about this in a little bit.. but I just wanna say:
For some reason, I was CONVINCED this entire time while watching, and for years now, that Tony dies at the end of the show. Boy I was glad I was wrong!
That entire finale, I just waited and waited for him to get killed. The ending was so intense... I love how it was left open to interpretation. I can see that being frustrating for some, but to me it was perfect. After rewatching a few times and doing hours of online reading etc.. I am in the "Tony Lives" camp.. for reasons I can go into later
I think they purposely put the shot on so many strange/seemingly threatening people in the shop to escalate the tension and make you think Tony was going to get killed. When the Italian guy went from the bar into the bathroom, I thought "oh shit, he has the piece in the bathroom and he's going to kill Tony like Michael killed the Turk and the cop in the Godfather"..
When it faded to black, I actually thought my episode was broken and not working. Again, I was CONVINCED he was supposed to die at the end, and thought I'd read multiple articles saying so. Now that I think back, I remember reading articles about the ending's controversy and people's speculation over its meaning.. including the idea that Tony does indeed die.
For some reason, over the last 8 years, my brain turned that into thinking Tony dies for sure. It's not something I thought about often, but when I decided to watch the show, I was convinced in my mind that it happens - my posts earlier in the thread reflect that.
Needless to say, I really loved this show and can't wait to watch it a 2nd time around. I always find that on second viewing, great works of film become even better. You already have absorbed the story and know the outcomes, and now the subtle details in every way - humor, drama, hints at the future, etc - start to be a lot more noticeable.
I just have nothing I can say that even comes close to explaining how much I loved this show. I watched all 86 hours in like 10 days or less I think.. Literally wake up, watch the show, go to bed type stuff. Never had that happen before, but I just could not get enough of it!
Tony is the GOAT