Dave's Song of the Day
Money Changes Everything – The Brains
Sunday song of the day: Today’s song was recorded and released twice by the original artist to very little commercial success, but became a hit when released by an established star.
In 1978, Tom Gray of the Atlanta-based band The Brains wrote a song titled
Money Changes Everything. It told the story a woman dumping the singer because she had found a rich boyfriend to replace him. It was not a situation taken from Gray’s own life, but the concept had come from a conversation he’d had with a friend. As he explains, “We were just sort of gossiping about this couple we knew, and she said, ‘She’s going to leave him as soon as she finds somebody with money.’ And I said, ‘Wait a minute, excuse me.’ The idea of the song just appeared in my head right there.”
The Brains recorded the song shortly afterward, and it was released on the local Gray Matter label. Both “The Brains” and Tom Gray’s name relate to “Gray Matter,” which is easy to explain since the band released the record themselves. They initially pressed 1,000 copies, then another thousand when the first batch sold out. It was not a hit, but it did get enough attention – specifically a glowing review from Robert Christgau in
The Village Voice – that Mercury Records signed the band.
Under the Mercury deal, The Brains released a self-titled debut album in 1980.
Money Changes Everything was rerecorded for the album and again released as a single. The original self-released single and the later album version had different second verses. Gray preferred the verse used on the original recording.
Unfortunately, the record’s release coincided with the sale of Mercury Records. All the people who had championed The Brains at the label were replaced, and the new regime did not promote the record at all, so it went nowhere.
It did gain enough attention that rising star Cyndi Lauper included
Money Changes Everything on her 1983 debut solo album,
She’s So Unusual. Lauper’s cover used the second verse that was included in the 1978 version by The Brains rather than their 1980 album version. In addition to that, the point of view was changed so that the song told of Lauper leaving her boyfriend instead of the other way around.
The first single from Lauper’s album,
Girls Just Want to Have Fun, was a huge hit, reaching #2 on the
Billboard Hot 100 chart. The next single,
Time After Time, reached #1, while the two after that were #3 and #5. Clearly she was on a roll, so in 1984
Money Changes Everything was released as the fifth single from the album. Few albums warrant the release of five singles, so Lauper’s cover version of The Brains’ song was saved from relegation as just another album track and became a hit single. While it didn’t reach the top 5 as the previous singles had, it did have a respectable showing at #27 on the
Billboard Hot 100.
The Brains, single, 1978
The Brains, album version, 1980
Cyndi Lauper cover, 1983
Tomorrow: Maybe I should have called you first