General So that didn't take long.... AFGHANISTAN

Welcome to our Community
Wanting to join the rest of our members? Feel free to Sign Up today.
Sign up
tang

tang

too high to rigg
Oct 21, 2015
9,403
12,399
Splinty said:
I see you conveniently left out in uniform.

Also some dude beating an officer illegally and bragging like it's cool isn't anything that has to do with this conversation.
Click to expand...
pretty sure he was in his uniform when he beat that dumb officer with the etool

yes. it's about calling out your leadership when they do dumb shit to put troops in harms way. we had a retarded SSGt in 04 Iraq, our platoon called him out and dude was relieved of his position and got his rifle taken away. It was because he was trying to instigate a friendly fire incident. when they do dumb shit, you call them out
 
D

Deleted member 1

Guest
tang said:
pretty sure he was in his uniform when he beat that dumb officer with the etool

yes. it's about calling out your leadership when they do dumb shit to put troops in harms way. we had a retarded SSGt in 04 Iraq, our platoon called him out and dude was relieved of his position and got his rifle taken away. It was because he was trying to instigate a friendly fire incident. when they do dumb shit, you call them out
Click to expand...
Did his subordinates "call him out" in uniform on an internet video?

Because if not you seem to not understand where your free speech ends and UCMJ begins.
 
tang

tang

too high to rigg
Oct 21, 2015
9,403
12,399
Splinty said:
Did his subordinates "call him out" in uniform on an internet video?

Because if not you seem to not understand where your free speech ends and UCMJ begins.
Click to expand...
you think it would have went differently if he requested mast?
 
D

Deleted member 1

Guest
tang said:
you think it would have went differently if he requested mast?
Click to expand...
I think your analogies and anecdotes are not accurate to the situation.

Take your uniform off if you want to comment on politics. Step carefully on the difference between criticizing actions and leaders themselves.
Or gtfo of the military and do whatever the hell you want. But it's service is voluntary and there's rules to it.
 
Freeloading Rusty

Freeloading Rusty

Here comes Rover, sniffin’ at your ass
Jan 11, 2016
26,916
26,589
jason73 said:
citizenfreepress.com

150 U.S. Military working dogs abandoned at Kabul Airport as last plane leaves…

150 U.S. Contract Military Dogs were left behind in Afghanistan Follow updates here as this story develops over the next 24 hours… Ther…
citizenfreepress.com citizenfreepress.com

View: https://twitter.com/JGilliam_SEAL/status/1432452904040927238
Click to expand...
More fake news..
www.militarytimes.com

No, the military did not leave its working dogs behind, DoD says

Contract working dogs, rather than military working dogs, appear to be the ones left behind.
www.militarytimes.com www.militarytimes.com

fox8.com

Pentagon says US didn’t leave service dogs in Afghanistan

The Pentagon is saying the United States did not leave any service dogs behind in Afghanistan, after a photo of animals left in cages went viral.
fox8.com fox8.com

"Photos circulating online were animals under the care of the Kabul Small Animal Rescue, not dogs under our care."
Click to expand...
 
tang

tang

too high to rigg
Oct 21, 2015
9,403
12,399
Splinty said:
I think your analogies and anecdotes are not accurate to the situation.

Take your uniform off if you want to comment on politics. Step carefully on the difference between criticizing actions and leaders themselves.
Or gtfo of the military and do whatever the hell you want. But it's service is voluntary and there's rules to it.
Click to expand...
he started his video with saying this is probably going to cost his career so i'm sure he's very aware of that and you're not wrong if it's coming straight from by the book officer perspective.

but if you're looking at from an enlisted perspective, the dude is a hero, every enlisted personnel supports this guy. He's an officer who is most respected in the infantry, someone who's not scared to speak his mind to the higher ups. Show me if you can find one enlisted Marine that thinks otherwise.

Sad thing about this is that it'll be only him who's going to take a loss, a big one, and no penalty for the ones who he's confronting, the ones who are really at fault.
Anyway you look at it, he's a courageous guy to step up and sacrifice his pension, only to get some accountability for the dead service member, something you or I can never do and i don't think it's fair to just label him as some nut job who has mental health issues.
 
Filthy

Filthy

Iowa Wrestling Champion
Jun 28, 2016
27,507
29,641
tang said:
he started his video with saying this is probably going to cost his career so i'm sure he's very aware of that and you're not wrong if it's coming straight from by the book officer perspective.

but if you're looking at from an enlisted perspective, the dude is a hero, every enlisted personnel supports this guy. He's an officer who is most respected in the infantry, someone who's not scared to speak his mind to the higher ups. Show me if you can find one enlisted Marine that thinks otherwise.

Sad thing about this is that it'll be only him who's going to take a loss, a big one, and no penalty for the ones who he's confronting, the ones who are really at fault.
Anyway you look at it, he's a courageous guy to step up and sacrifice his pension, only to get some accountability for the dead service member, something you or I can never do and i don't think it's fair to just label him as some nut job who has mental health issues.
Click to expand...
no one is asking enlisted Marines what they think.

ever.
 
Filthy

Filthy

Iowa Wrestling Champion
Jun 28, 2016
27,507
29,641
Former Maycee Barber Fan said:
Meme could have been better. Makes the Kurds look like stereotypical terrorists and it could have showed a female YPG fighter to emphasize the ridiculousness of the 'we need to stay in Afghanistan to protect women' narrative too.
Click to expand...
did you just assume that Kurdish cartoon's gender?
 
Filthy

Filthy

Iowa Wrestling Champion
Jun 28, 2016
27,507
29,641
tang said:
that's not the point.

respect from everyone under the rank of that Lt.Col, all the higher ups are the ones hating
Click to expand...
i think most people, especially enlisted, see him as a transparent attention-whore who thought he could make himself a poster boy because he had a couple years left on a dead end career.

even enlisted Marines aren't that easily duped. They know that he's trying to sign them and their kids up for rotations in Afghanistan.
 
tang

tang

too high to rigg
Oct 21, 2015
9,403
12,399
T-City Minister of Truth said:
i think most people, especially enlisted, see him as a transparent attention-whore who thought he could make himself a poster boy because he had a couple years left on a dead end career.

even enlisted Marines aren't that easily duped. They know that he's trying to sign them and their kids up for rotations in Afghanistan.
Click to expand...
where are you getting this info from?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom