Provided? Did you give him different sizes and let him try? I could see that being weird, but if you do it, you have to go the whole nine yards I guess.
Yes, girls can be thrown off by so many things, and sometimes their freak-outs are just... idiotic.
I was with a girl once and didn't have condoms on me, but she did. I wanted to get some since suspected it wouldn’t work, but she didn't want to wait. And well, they didn't fit.
She called me an idiot and tried it herself a couple times (with force and those dumb nails, it hurt!). Only to explode then.
I mean, you could take the situation with a laugh and just do something different, or actually get the right condoms. But she started yelling at me and threw me out like in the movies with clothes flying after me. Just outside her room though and luckily nobody else was around (shared flat), but still.
Makes you feel like a broken toy! But its also funny after a while.