General Who was the most talented MUSICIAN to come out of the Seattle grunge scene?

Welcome to our Community
Wanting to join the rest of our members? Feel free to Sign Up today.
Sign up
GentleArt309

GentleArt309

Active Member
Aug 14, 2024
83
123
Late 80's/early 90's we saw the scene blow up in the PNW and soon the entire world knew these people. Lots of great bands like Nirvana, AIC, Mudhoney, Pearl Jam, Green River, Soundgarden, STP.... so my question is who was the single most talented musician to come out of that particlar scene specifically form the PNW?

I know who gets me vote, but I wanna see what you guys think!
 
sparkuri

sparkuri

Pulse on the finger of The Cimmunity
First 100
Jan 16, 2015
38,173
50,195
STP was San Diego.

Also Gruntruck, Screaming Trees, Mother Love Bone etc.
Before that Queensryche....Heart....Jimi Hendrix.....

I guess most will say Dave Grohl, but Chris Cornell is one of the greatest wailers I've ever heard.

Can't timestamp so head to 1:45


View: https://youtu.be/gh20q3Dx8RI?si=BelMzsjK7121xaIB


Screenshot_20240917_100036.jpg
 
Last edited:
Masterclass

Masterclass

Has doggos that's cooler
Nov 18, 2023
80
172
Dave for sure if we're going on pure talent as the thread states. Chris had the highest talent peak in one area with that voice' but Dave has literally been a one man band, a member of a cornerstone band from Seattle in the 90s during the grunge explosion, and still putting out chart topping music this long after initially finding fame.
 
Last edited:
Hauler

Hauler

Been fallin so long it's like gravitys gone
Feb 3, 2016
47,940
60,005
Dave Grohl
Hands down.

Although Ohio still claims him as a Buckeye.
 
CasketCaseZombie

CasketCaseZombie

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2024
340
527
I like Jerry Cantrell. Most talented? I don’t know, but he’s my pick anyway. Maybe because he’s the only one I’ve ever seen live.
 
HARLEM

HARLEM

Formerly 'smilin'
Feb 25, 2015
317
1,094
vocalist - hard to argue with Chris Cornell or Layne Staley.
Electric Guitar - Jimi
 
HARLEM

HARLEM

Formerly 'smilin'
Feb 25, 2015
317
1,094
whoops. I didn’t see the 80’s 90’s window. You are right.

Dean De Leo was unique. McCreedy, Stone, Jerry Cantrell, Kim Thaylil. They all had different unique giftings. Hard to single one out.

You could throw Jack Endino as a guitarist who later did sound Engineering for Sub Pop and mixed for a lot of these groups. His ear influenced a lot of the music in the grunge era.
 
NiteProwleR

NiteProwleR

Free Hole Lay Row
Nov 17, 2023
3,481
5,461
sparkuri

sparkuri

Pulse on the finger of The Cimmunity
First 100
Jan 16, 2015
38,173
50,195
kvr28

kvr28

I am the Greengo
Nov 22, 2015
8,867
13,034
I have to go with grohl just because of his longevity and his body of work.
 
GentleArt309

GentleArt309

Active Member
Aug 14, 2024
83
123
I always lean to Jerry Cantrell. His song writing, guitar playing, and vocals all hit all the time. I hoinestly thing AIC was the most talent band of that time period. Even thgouh Nirvana was my fav band. Maybe the simplicity of Kurts musc and playing was easier to sit down and immitate.

Grohl is just an incredible musician. But honestly he hasnt done anything the last 20 years that didnt seem like a repeat of something he had alerady wrote. I do love the guy though.
 
sparkuri

sparkuri

Pulse on the finger of The Cimmunity
First 100
Jan 16, 2015
38,173
50,195
GentleArt309 said:
I always lean to Jerry Cantrell. His song writing, guitar playing, and vocals all hit all the time. I hoinestly thing AIC was the most talent band of that time period. Even thgouh Nirvana was my fav band. Maybe the simplicity of Kurts musc and playing was easier to sit down and immitate.

Grohl is just an incredible musician. But honestly he hasnt done anything the last 20 years that didnt seem like a repeat of something he had alerady wrote. I do love the guy though.
Click to expand...
I knew it was either Grohl or Cantrell.
I once worked with a guy a little over 20 years ago who wore a Jerry Cantrell hardhat.
Those who know, know.
 
sparkuri

sparkuri

Pulse on the finger of The Cimmunity
First 100
Jan 16, 2015
38,173
50,195
GentleArt309 said:
The 90's was different. I dont kow if thats bc it was my comnig of age years (graduated HS in 95) or what. But there hasnt been a time like it. Maybe 9/11 has somethign to do with it too.
Click to expand...
, 9/11, Patriot Act, war on humanity...
80's & 90's were essentially "Murica fuck yeah, even with the gulf war.
Hell I had Desert Shield & Desert Storm trading cards.
Entertainment hit its peak, "BBQ's & ballgames" with a somewhat invincible feeling.
 
B

Bungee up

Active Member
Jun 25, 2022
179
170
Dave Grohl wasn't really from Seattle.
Even though he hooked up with nirvana he was from the coast. I can see an argument either way but not sure if he counts .
 
sparkuri

sparkuri

Pulse on the finger of The Cimmunity
First 100
Jan 16, 2015
38,173
50,195
Bungee up said:
Dave Grohl wasn't really from Seattle.
Even though he hooked up with nirvana he was from the coast. I can see an argument either way but not sure if he counts .
Click to expand...
Dave was like from the eastern U.S., not from either coast.
But that's really not the question as rock stars are often like franchise athletes.
Kurt was from ,Aberdeen so good enough.
Most others were basically from Seattle area, Stone Gossard, Jeff Ament, Layne, Cornell, Thayil, Andrew Wood, Ben Shepard, Matt Cameron, etc.
Eddie Vedder was basically from San Diego, not sure about the Candlebox crew.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom