British brothers and sisters, y'all wearing poppies or nah?

Welcome to our Community
Wanting to join the rest of our members? Feel free to Sign Up today.
Sign up

Are you wearing a poppy?

  • Yes. God save the Queen!

    Votes: 9 37.5%
  • No. Ain't nobody got time for that.

    Votes: 1 4.2%
  • Are you aving a laugh?

    Votes: 3 12.5%
  • U Wot M8?

    Votes: 11 45.8%

  • Total voters
    24
Jan 21, 2015
3,255
6,053
You are 100%, but my opinion still stands. I've known plenty of Muslims outside of combat zones. If it's in a professional environment I deal with them in a professional manner but there is zero small talk or outside interaction. If it's outside of work I don't acknowledge them. I don't trust them farther than I can throw them.
What if he's like a really big guy who you couldn't throw very far?

Would you trust him then?
 

Ted Williams' head

It's freezing in here!
Sep 23, 2015
11,283
19,071
You're entitled to your opinion. I have travelled a lot and lived a colourful life. I have Muslim friends that hate the extremists. Just because you've seen Muslims do some awful stuff, doesn't mean all Muslims are tarred with the same brush.

Some Americans have done atrocious things but I wouldn't judge all Americans.
I will say as an agnostic who thinks all organized religions are rather silly, the Islamic belief system I find particularly appalling. While I have no malice or hate in my heart for any Muslim person, I can't say that I like or respect a religion that has the views and treatment it does of women, homosexuals, apostates, ect. Equality, human rights... these things do not exist as we know them in Muslim-run countries.

And before anyone responds with the predictable "YEAH BUT CHRISTIANITY"... yeah, I'm not a fan of Christianity either.

I think it's fine to separate the people from the belief system. No problem with Muslims, not a fan of the religion.

I agree with Bill Maher when he says Islam is the "motherlode of bad ideas".
 

Leigh

Engineer
Pro Fighter
Jan 26, 2015
10,912
21,059
I will say as an agnostic who thinks all organized religions are rather silly, the Islamic belief system I find particularly appalling. While I have no malice or hate in my heart for any Muslim person, I can't say that I like or respect a religion that has the views and treatment it does of women, homosexuals, apostates, ect. Equality, human rights... these things do not exist as we know them in Muslim-run countries.

And before anyone responds with the predictable "YEAH BUT CHRISTIANITY"... yeah, I'm not a fan of Christianity either.

I think it's fine to separate the people from the belief system. No problem with Muslims, not a fan of the religion.
The Quran has some horrific stuff in there, no two ways about it, but I don't think it's any worse than the Torah/OT. Islam is a horrible ideology based in a horrible part of the world and some Muslims commit horrific acts of barbarism and terrorism.

But that can also be said about the Bible. Christians in Africa do appalling things. George Bush is a Christian and is responsible for many innocent deaths. Christians in the UK committed horrible terrorism.

I am not defending Islam; I consider it a disease. But it's not really any worse than the other Abrahamic religions (although I'd rather be mates with Jesus than Mohammad).
 

Ted Williams' head

It's freezing in here!
Sep 23, 2015
11,283
19,071
But that can also be said about the Bible. Christians in Africa do appalling things. George Bush is a Christian and is responsible for many innocent deaths. Christians in the UK committed horrible terrorism.
Not to mention all the kiddy fiddling.
 

Ted Williams' head

It's freezing in here!
Sep 23, 2015
11,283
19,071
There are a lot of double standards with our treatment of Islam, though, because it's a religion (generally speaking) made up of non-white people. It's very easy to get branded a racist/bigot for speaking out against it, whereas the Catholic church has always been fair game.

Here in Canada, I think there is a genuine resentment that builds from Muslims coming in and trying to change our established laws and customs. We've had Muslim university students demand that women cannot work with them or in their groups, Muslims going into martial arts dojos and demanding that women train on the other side of the gym, demanding Islamic praying stations build into schools (which are supposed to be non-denominational to the point where you can't even put up a Christmas tree), demanding their faces be concealed in situations where you're not allowed to conceal your face, ect. People start viewing it as invasive, instead of just multiculturalism.
 

ThatOneDude

Commander in @Chief, Dick Army
First 100
Jan 14, 2015
35,368
34,139
There are a lot of double standards with our treatment of Islam, though, because it's a religion (generally speaking) made up of non-white people. It's very easy to get branded a racist/bigot for speaking out against it, whereas the Catholic church has always been fair game.

Here in Canada, I think there is a genuine resentment that builds from Muslims coming in and trying to change our established laws and customs. We've had Muslim university students demand that women cannot work with them or in their groups, Muslims going into martial arts dojos and demanding that women train on the other side of the gym, demanding Islamic praying stations build into schools (which are supposed to be non-denominational to the point where you can't even put up a Christmas tree), demanding their faces be concealed in situations where you're not allowed to conceal your face, ect. People start viewing it as invasive, instead of just multiculturalism.
I said all of this privately yesterday. Muslims are a protected class because people are afraid of offending them and/or being killed because of it. Look what they did in Texas because some people drew some mean pictures of a child fucker.
 

Leigh

Engineer
Pro Fighter
Jan 26, 2015
10,912
21,059
There are a lot of double standards with our treatment of Islam, though, because it's a religion (generally speaking) made up of non-white people. It's very easy to get branded a racist/bigot for speaking out against it, whereas the Catholic church has always been fair game.

Here in Canada, I think there is a genuine resentment that builds from Muslims coming in and trying to change our established laws and customs. We've had Muslim university students demand that women cannot work with them or in their groups, Muslims going into martial arts dojos and demanding that women train on the other side of the gym, demanding Islamic praying stations build into schools (which are supposed to be non-denominational to the point where you can't even put up a Christmas tree), demanding their faces be concealed in situations where you're not allowed to conceal your face, ect. People start viewing it as invasive, instead of just multiculturalism.
Are these foreign Muslim students or Canadian Muslim students?
 

Leigh

Engineer
Pro Fighter
Jan 26, 2015
10,912
21,059
Does it honestly matter?
Yes. His statement is, "Here in Canada, I think there is a genuine resentment that builds from Muslims coming in and trying to change our established laws and customs."

If they're born there, they aren't coming in, they're Canadian citizens who want change. Not a change I agree with but I get sick of the facebook posts about "They wouldn't let us go to their countries and change their laws," and "If they don't like it, they should go back to their own countries."

In my experience, the vocal Muslims are native citizens, not immigrants. I'm sure you can dig up some examples but it will be a tiny fraction of Muslim immigrants. Immigrants come to our countries because they like them, not because they want to change them.
 

ThatOneDude

Commander in @Chief, Dick Army
First 100
Jan 14, 2015
35,368
34,139
Yes. His statement is, "Here in Canada, I think there is a genuine resentment that builds from Muslims coming in and trying to change our established laws and customs."

If they're born there, they aren't coming in, they're Canadian citizens who want change. Not a change I agree with but I get sick of the facebook posts about "They wouldn't let us go to their countries and change their laws," and "If they don't like it, they should go back to their own countries."

In my experience, the vocal Muslims are native citizens, not immigrants. I'm sure you can dig up some examples but it will be a tiny fraction of Muslim immigrants. Immigrants come to our countries because they like them, not because they want to change them.
Either way it's the same issue. In western civilization our governments shouldn't be held hostage by religious groups, I don't care what group it is. Freedom to practice your religion should be about as involved as governments get in religion. So Muslims or anyone for that matter who wants to bring their religious agenda into the legal system and government in general is wrong and a dangerous precedent, they can go back to the 3rd world countries who use religion to rule, has no place in modern society.
 

Ted Williams' head

It's freezing in here!
Sep 23, 2015
11,283
19,071
Yes. His statement is, "Here in Canada, I think there is a genuine resentment that builds from Muslims coming in and trying to change our established laws and customs."

If they're born there, they aren't coming in, they're Canadian citizens who want change. Not a change I agree with but I get sick of the facebook posts about "They wouldn't let us go to their countries and change their laws," and "If they don't like it, they should go back to their own countries."

In my experience, the vocal Muslims are native citizens, not immigrants. I'm sure you can dig up some examples but it will be a tiny fraction of Muslim immigrants. Immigrants come to our countries because they like them, not because they want to change them.
I really haven't seen that from Canadian-born or long term Canadian Muslims. Always foreign students and new Canadians.

"If they don't like it, they should go back to their own countries."

This view has become synonymous with the closed-minded, but I think at times there is something to that. Here in Canada (and in many other countries), we promote certain values of equality and tolerance. If your views make it impossible for you to exist within this system, I think it might be best for all parties that you choose another country to migrate to.
 

Leigh

Engineer
Pro Fighter
Jan 26, 2015
10,912
21,059
Additionally, I'm not partial to the culture
Either way it's the same issue. In western civilization our governments shouldn't be held hostage by religious groups, I don't care what group it is. Freedom to practice your religion should be about as involved as governments get in religion. So Muslims or anyone for that matter who wants to bring their religious agenda into the legal system and government in general is wrong and a dangerous precedent, they can go back to the 3rd world countries who use religion to rule, has no place in modern society.
I agree. Let's just not try to rally nationalist support based on false fear mongering. These are British citizens trying to influence British culture, Canadian citizens trying to influence Canadian culture etc. Let's focus on the actual issue, so that we can address it properly; keep religion out of government and the legal system.
 

Leigh

Engineer
Pro Fighter
Jan 26, 2015
10,912
21,059
I really haven't seen that from Canadian-born or long term Canadian Muslims. Always foreign students and new Canadians.

"If they don't like it, they should go back to their own countries."

This view has become synonymous with the closed-minded, but I think at times there is something to that. Here in Canada (and in many other countries), we promote certain values of equality and tolerance. If your views make it impossible for you to exist within this system, I think it might be best for all parties that you choose another country to migrate to.
I think you're making straw man. Sure, if immigrants can't assimilate, they shouldn't come. But I don't think that's usually the case
 

ThatOneDude

Commander in @Chief, Dick Army
First 100
Jan 14, 2015
35,368
34,139
Additionally, I'm not partial to the culture

I agree. Let's just not try to rally nationalist support based on false fear mongering. These are British citizens trying to influence British culture, Canadian citizens trying to influence Canadian culture etc. Let's focus on the actual issue, so that we can address it properly; keep religion out of government and the legal system.
Yea I agree. Except other religions don't say if you don't convert then you should be killed or you need to pay a tax.
 

jason73

Auslander Raus
First 100
Jan 15, 2015
75,621
139,133
canada has millions of chinese and east indians immigrants who do just fine .they intergrate part of their society and also have their own communities.there is no hostilities towards canadians and they even adopt our customs such as christmas and halloween even though they still worship at a temple.muslims have zero interest in assimilating
 

ThatOneDude

Commander in @Chief, Dick Army
First 100
Jan 14, 2015
35,368
34,139
canada has millions of chinese and east indians immigrants who do just fine .they intergrate part of their society and also have their own communities.there is no hostilities towards canadians and they even adopt our customs such as christmas and halloween even though they still worship at a temple.muslims have zero interest in assimilating
Your bigotry is showing
 

Leigh

Engineer
Pro Fighter
Jan 26, 2015
10,912
21,059
Yea I agree. Except other religions don't say if you don't convert then you should be killed or you need to pay a tax.
Have you read the Bible? God killed everyone on the planet for not doing what he said. I have had educated Christians tell me that these people deserved it.
How am I making a straw man? You just agreed with my statement.
Because most Muslim immigrants are fine and a majority of Muslim problems are from native citizens.
canada has millions of chinese and east indians immigrants who do just fine .they intergrate part of their society and also have their own communities.there is no hostilities towards canadians and they even adopt our customs such as christmas and halloween even though they still worship at a temple.muslims have zero interest in assimilating
As a person with Chinese heritage who lived in Canada for two years and with a lot of Chinese family who immigrated to Canada, I disagree. There are a lot of Chinese people who are critical of the Canadian system and there are a lot of problems with East Indians. Chinese people were crying racism when it was simply suggested that those moving to Canada have an understanding of the English language. But in fairness, yet again, those are usually people born there and are a small percentage of their group. Just like with Muslims.